Faulty Cellar Grate Leads to Fatal Fall for Brooklyn Man

Goldstein and Bashner | New York City Injuries

I’ll be looking twice, and avoiding grates in sidewalks. I just don’t trust them anymore, not after seeing so many accidents resulting in injuries and fatalities. This weekend, a man in Brooklyn died after falling through a cellar grate.

The man was reportedly walking on Bedford Avenue when he stepped onto the grate. Suddenly, the metal doors of the grate collapsed and the man fell 12 feet down. According to the New York Daily News, the doors led to the basement of an abandoned building.

“The thing just opened. He was walking. He wasn’t paying attention,” witness Richie McCray said. “The thing is loose. And he disappeared.”

Who is At Fault When Someone Falls Down A Cellar Grate on A Sidewalk?

You may be wondering who is at fault when these accidents happen. It really varies case by case. City law dictates that property owners are held responsible for injuries or deaths caused by improperly secured cellar grates. However, when it comes to sidewalk grates and vaults, New York case law has concluded that the owners of the grates and access covers – usually utility companies, transit authorities or the city – are the ones liable for injuries caused by inadequate grate maintenance. The defect must be within 12 inches of the sidewalk grate though. If the hardware was installed for the benefit of an adjoining landowner, the beneficiary of this hardware may be responsible for its defective condition, even if not the owner. There were 40 complaints last year for unstable cellar doors in New York City, and 19 complaints have been filed so far in 2015.

To learn more about accidents involving sidewalk grates, manholes and access covers, read our article. If you have been seriously injured from falling through a sidewalk grate, or access cover in Long Island or NYC, please contact us today at 516-203-4857. Our compassionate lawyers will answer any questions you have. You may have a case and be entitled to compensation for you injuries.

Neal A. Goldstein
Goldstein and Bashner
We know you have questions, so Goldstein and Bashner offers a number of free reports and information on this website.
1778 Hempstead Turnpike East Meadow, NY 11554
(516) 874-7303 516-222-0034
$
Robert Bashner
Goldstein and Bashner
We know you have questions, so Goldstein and Bashner offers a number of free reports and information on this website.
1778 Hempstead Turnpike East Meadow, NY 11554
(516) 874-7303 516-222-0034
$

Goldstein & Bashner

1778 Hempstead Turnpike East Meadow, NY 11554
(516) 874-7303 516-222-0034
$
Goldstein & Bashner
New York Office New York, NY 10170
212-349-2181 Neal A. Goldstein Robert Bashner Facebook Twitter Linkedin Google
Goldstein & Bashner
Nassau County Office 1778 Hempstead Turnpike East Meadow, NY 11554
(516) 874-7303 516-222-0034 Neal A. Goldstein Robert Bashner FB Twitter Linkedin Google
Goldstein & Bashner
Suffolk County Office Central Islip, NY 11722
631-851-2063 516-222-0034 Neal A. Goldstein Robert Bashner FB Twitter Linkedin Google
Goldstein and Bashner When it comes to the capacity to generate profound upheaval and anguish in the lives of those involved, almost nothing rivals a serious personal injury event stemming from the negligence of others. The physical suffering, financial pressures and family strain that so often result from such circumstances can seem insurmountable unless justice and accountability can be obtained from those responsible.